However, other critics have challenged this view as a mere criticism or rather a stereotypical subversion of masculinity.
The unnamed narrator in Fight Club depicts a man struggling with personal loss of power.
According to Fight Club, Tyler has found his masculine identity and the members of Fight Club are able to do this as well by enduring the pain of Fight Club and not conforming to society’s standards.
Fight club essay masculinity and femininity 1
Thus, the narrator’s frequent use of action (as is in fight club) instead of language in the effort to build a relationship with his peers show his discrepancy between his own lived experiences and the inherited language of masculinity (Baker 78).
The narrator is not only a “generation of men raised by women”, but also a victim of consumer capitalism resulting from post-war masculinity and hegemonic Cold-War masculinity that demanded men “to define themselves through their identities as consumers.”
A fleet of painful and stress provoking events and the need to compensate for his personal masculine insecurities forces the narrator to adopt alternate personality – that of Tyler (an imaginary confident, tough, handsome street fighter with the freedom and power to do act he pleases).
Gay Criticism – Literary Theory and Criticism Notes
You are the all-singing, all-dancing crap of the world.” This is the underlying message in Fincher’s Fight Club (1999), which satirically analyzes and critiques consumerism.
OFS Hodonín - Okresní fotbalový svaz
Chuck’s prominent, pessimistic, radical work, Fight Club, investigates inner self deeper and deeper into personality, identity, and temperament as a chapter goes by....
What I Learned Working at a Strip Club | HuffPost
These are issues that become weighty under the dictates of hegemonic masculinity as a result of the ensuing alienation.
In the same vein, the narrator intensely ponders on the apparent frailty of ethics relating to hegemonic norm of manhood while in a meeting with Microsoft representatives after he establishes the first Fight Club.